May 27, 2025
When a loved one passes away, an estate trustee (formerly known as an executor) is appointed to administer their estate according to the instructions in the will. The estate trustee has a legal duty to act in the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries. However, there may be situations where replacing the estate trustee becomes necessary. Whether due to a conflict of interest, misconduct, or incapacity, it is important to understand the process for removing and replacing an estate trustee in Ontario.
In this article, we will walk you through the steps for replacing an estate trustee in Ontario, the reasons why it might be necessary, and the legal considerations involved.
- What Is an Estate Trustee?
In Ontario, an estate trustee is a person (or institution) named in the will to manage and distribute the deceased’s estate. The estate trustee’s duties include:
-
- Locating and gathering the deceased’s assets
- Paying debts and taxes
- Distributing the estate to beneficiaries according to the will
- Keeping proper records of all estate-related activities
The estate trustee is a fiduciary, meaning they must act in the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries, avoiding any conflicts of interest.
- Reasons for Replacing an Estate Trustee
There are several reasons why a person might want to replace an estate trustee, including:
-
- Incapacity: The appointed trustee may become ill or otherwise incapable of carrying out their duties.
- Conflict of Interest: The trustee may have a personal interest that conflicts with the best interests of the estate, such as being a beneficiary themselves.
- Mismanagement: If the trustee fails to carry out their duties responsibly, such as failing to file tax returns, failing to account for estate funds, or making improper distributions, they may be removed.
- Dishonesty or Fraud: If the trustee is suspected of dishonesty, theft, or fraud, they may need to be replaced.
- Voluntary Resignation: Sometimes, the estate trustee may simply decide they no longer wish to act in this capacity and may request to step down.
Regardless of the reason, if an estate trustee is not fulfilling their duties, beneficiaries or other interested parties may take legal action to have them replaced.
- How to Remove and Replace an Estate Trustee in Ontario
Replacing an estate trustee in Ontario requires legal action, and there are specific steps involved in the process. The procedure generally involves filing a motion with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice.
Step 1: Review the Will
The first step in the process is to review the will to confirm the estate trustee’s appointment. If the will specifies a substitute trustee or a procedure for removing or replacing the trustee, that should be followed. For example, the will might state that a certain person should take over if the original trustee is unable to act.
If no alternative trustee is named in the will, the court will appoint someone to replace the estate trustee.
Step 2: Attempt to Resolve the Issue Amicably
Before taking legal action, it is advisable to try to resolve the issue with the estate trustee directly. If the trustee is willing to step down voluntarily, this can simplify the process. The estate trustee should formally resign in writing and provide a signed resignation document.
In some cases, a mediator or lawyer may be able to help resolve disputes between the trustee and beneficiaries, potentially avoiding the need for a court application.
Step 3: What Happens If the Estate Trustee Refuses to Step Down?
If an estate trustee refuses to step down or is unwilling to cooperate with the process, it is important to gather evidence of the trustee’s failure to act properly or their inability to fulfill their duties. If necessary, the applicant can ask the court to order the trustee’s removal.
The court will typically consider the following when deciding whether to remove a trustee:
-
- The nature and extent of the trustee’s failure to act properly
- Any negative impact the trustee’s actions have had on the estate or its beneficiaries
- Whether the trustee has been given an opportunity to respond or correct their behavior
- The best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries
The court will make a decision based on what it believes is in the best interest of the estate and its beneficiaries.
Step 4: File a Motion with the Court
If the issue cannot be resolved amicably or if the trustee refuses to step down, the next step is to file a motion with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice to replace the estate trustee. The motion is a formal application requesting the court to remove the current trustee and appoint a new one.
When filing the motion, the applicant (usually a beneficiary or interested party) must provide evidence supporting the need for a change. This evidence may include:
-
- Proof of the trustee’s incapacity or misconduct
- Documents showing the trustee’s failure to meet their obligations (e.g., failure to file taxes, mismanagement of estate funds)
- Statements from beneficiaries or others with knowledge of the trustee’s actions
It is important to include all relevant details and to clearly demonstrate why removing the trustee is in the best interest of the estate.
Step 5: Appointing a New Estate Trustee
If the court agrees that the current estate trustee should be replaced, it will appoint a new estate trustee. The applicant may propose a suitable replacement, or the court may appoint someone else, including a family member, professional trustee, or even a public trustee.
The new trustee will be required to file their own Affidavit of Estate Trustee to officially take over the estate administration process. The new trustee will also be required to notify all interested parties of the change in trusteeship.
- Legal Considerations When Replacing an Estate Trustee
Replacing an estate trustee can be a complex and emotional process. Here are a few important legal considerations:
-
- Costs: The costs associated with replacing an estate trustee, including court fees, legal fees, and any other associated expenses, are typically borne by the estate. However, if the replacement is due to misconduct, the original trustee may be required to cover these costs.
- Timeline: The process of removing and replacing a trustee can take time, especially if the issue is contested. It is important to plan for potential delays.
- Disputes: Disputes over the replacement of an estate trustee can lead to further litigation, which may delay the distribution of the estate. Mediation or settlement negotiations may help resolve issues more quickly.
How Weilers LLP Can Help You
Replacing an estate trustee in Ontario is a serious legal matter that requires careful consideration and action. Whether due to incapacity, mismanagement, conflict of interest, or other issues, the process of removing and replacing an estate trustee involves legal steps that may require court intervention. It’s essential to have an experienced estate lawyer by your side to navigate this process and ensure the best possible outcome for the estate and its beneficiaries.
If you’re dealing with issues related to an estate trustee in Ontario, contact Weilers LLP’s experienced estate law team for advice and assistance. We can guide you through the process of replacing an estate trustee, protecting the interests of the estate, and ensuring the proper administration of the estate according to the wishes of the deceased. If the process becomes contested, Weilers LLP estate lawyers work seamlessly with our litigation team, which is experienced in estate disputes.
Give us a call. We may be the right lawyers for you.